Political News and Commentary with the Right Perspective. NAVIGATION
  • Front Page
  • News
  • Multimedia
  • Tags
  • RSS Feed


  • Advertise on RightMichigan.com


    NEWS TIPS!

    Get the RightMighigan.com toolbar!


    RightMichigan.com

    Buzz

    Who are the NERD fund donors Mr Snyder?

    Raise the curtain.

    Because The Narrative Cannot Survive A Rewrite


    By Kevin Rex Heine, Section News
    Posted on Thu Mar 01, 2012 at 04:35:21 PM EST
    Tags: "DELE-GATE", Bobby Schostak, Sharon Wise, Saul Anuzis, Holly Hughes, Eric Doster, Mike Cox, Bill Runco, MIGOP Credentials Committee, backroom shenanigans, disingenuous hypocrisy, Mitt Romney, Rick Santorum, primary process, delegate math, ex post facto rules changes, memory holes (all tags)

    Yesterday, I wrote that Mitt Romney's campaign leadership in Michigan was doing their damnedest to spin Michigan's Presidential Primary results into a win for "Michigan's Native Son."  If they could successfully do so, then it would preserve their desired narrative that the favorite son of a popular governor had defeated an insurrection in his own backyard, and would now heroically go forward and accomplish that which his father was unable to do a generation ago.

    However, facts are stubborn things.  As the day wore on, the truth started to make its way to the beltway media that the real result of the Michigan Primary is an exact split of the delegation (which, according to Tony Roza over at The Green Papers, would have been the result even if we hadn't been penalized).  Since such an outcome might have derailed the Romney coronation train, something had to be done.  At the eleventh hour, something was done.


    A bit of background first.

    Per the rules, the Michigan Republican Party has 55 days to certify the results of the Michigan Republican Presidential Primary.  That means that this matrix currently available on the MIGOP website (which I took a screenshot of yesterday, and date-time stamped it just in case) is officially unofficial until 23 April.  Until that time, the state committee isn't required to actually comment on those results.  It's mathematically possible that CD-05 and/or CD-10 could flip over into the Santorum column during the certification process, because they're that close, but it's very unlikely that they'll do so.

    Now, you won't find this anywhere in the 39-page 2011 Michigan Republican Party Directory, but the Credentials Committee consists of seven people, as follows:

    • Bobby Schostak (Party Chair)
    • Sharon Wise (Party Co-Chair)
    • Saul Anuzis (National Committeeman)
    • Holly Hughes (National Committeewoman)
    • Eric Doster (General Counsel)
    • Mike Cox (Policy Committee Chair)
    • Bill Runco (Budget Committee Chair)

    That same committee met last night, literally in the dark of night, without notifying anyone, and voted 4-2 to give both of Michigan's at-large delegates to Mitt "Native Son" Romney.  Never mind that there is absolutely no provision anywhere in either the state party or national party rules that would allow for this action, and never mind that MIGOP rule 19-C(2) absolutely requires the 15-15 split that I discussed in this article from yesterday.  Evidently the heavy hand of Romney supporters on the committee decided that they were going to ignore the rules because they didn't care for the public and above-board outcome.

    From "MI GOP Credentials Committee Gives Romney 2 At-Large Delegates" (MIRS Breaking News - 01 March 2012 @ 12:44):

    The Michigan Republican Party (MRP) Credentials Committee voted 4-2 last night to give Mitt Romney both of the state's at-large delegates, State Policy Committee Chair Mike Cox told MIRS today.

    Cox was one of two "no" votes on the committee which met via telephone, along with attorney Eric Doster  The "yes" votes included GOP National Committeeman Saul Anuzis, a Romney supporter, and MRP Chair Bobby Schostak.

    That would put the delegate split at 16 for Romney and 14 for Rick Santorum, after each candidate won 14 delegates apiece in those divided by Michigan's 14 congressional districts.

    As MIRS first reported on Wednesday, the MRP was delaying a final decision on the delegate split until after consulting with attorneys.

    Cox said that according to the MRP rules, Santorum and Romney should each get one of Michigan's two at-large delegates based on their take of the popular vote.

    "I supported Mitt, but the vote was clearly wrong," Cox said of the Credentials Committee.  "It's kind of like Third World voting.  We published rules and then we voted to change the rules."

    He said he expects the Santorum campaign to file a complaint with the Republican National Committee (RNC).

    The Santorum campaign filing a complaint . . . you think so?  That means that if this backroom band "decision" isn't reversed before the MIGOP State Convention in May, then Michigan (along with Florida and Arizona) will have an "under appeal" flag sitting beside any honest report of its delegate count.  This will be for no other reason than that in an actual middle of the night, smoke-filled backroom, Team Romney and the Michigan Republican Party establishment elites voted to ignore the results of Tuesday's Primary Election and ex post facto disregard the party's own rules (which were submitted to the Republican National Committee on February 7, 2012).

    So far as I'm aware, the vote tally on the question was as follows:

    Voting "no":
    • Eric Doster
    • Mike Cox

    Voting "yes":
    • Bobby Schostak
    • Sharon Wise
    • Saul Anuzis
    • Bill Runco

    According to what I've learned, Holly Hughes was not notified of the meeting until after the vote was taken, thus the reason for a missing vote.  I haven't had a chance to speak with Ms. Hughes directly, but I know her well enough to suspect that she would have voted "no" had she been present.  I'm told that as I write this, she's making many phone calls to protest the decision.

    Of course, this morning, none other than Saul Anuzis released a statement on how last night's meeting didn't actually violate the rules.  From That's Saul, Folks!:

    At the February 4th State Committee meeting held in Lansing, the Credentials Committee unanimously passed the procedures for allocating Michigan's delegates to the National Convention in the event that the RNC imposes the 50% penalty on our delegation.

    Last night the Credentials Committee met via teleconference and voted to apply the rules as passed unanimously on February 4th which results in the 2 at large delegates being awarded to the statewide winner, Mitt Romney.

    There were no changes in rules or procedures, the Credential Committee only ratified the existing rules as previously passed after some made erroneous claims to the media that the at-large delegates would be split.

    There is no disagreement amongst the members that this was the intent of the Credential Committee and there is email traffic between the committee members and counsel discussing the same.

    Regrettably, there was an error in the memo drafted and sent to the respective campaigns.  There were questions raised at the time the memo was drafted as to whether the legal language used was accomplishing the goal of the committee and we were advised that it was, but now it is clear that the memo did not properly communicate the intent of the committee.  The email traffic surrounding the drafting of the memo in early February makes explicitly clear what the intent of the committee was.

    The committee convened again last night to affirm that the intent was clear and that the memo was inaccurate.  That affirmation came in a 4-2 vote.  While we all regret the error in the memo, it does not change what was voted on by the committee, which was to award the two at-large delegates to the statewide winner.  It was premature for any candidate to be declaring the delegate count prior to an official announcement by the Michigan Republican Party

    Yup, nothing to see here, folks; just a miscommunication with regard to the intent of our original memorandum.  Everyone's in agreement that the earlier memo was wrong, and now we're doing it the right way.  We're moving along now.

    Except that the memo that Saul links to was put out by Kim Jorns (MIGOP Executive Director) just this morning!  Conspicuous by its absence is a link to the original memo (dated February 7, 2012) that was sent to all four candidate campaigns and copied directly to Reince Priebus.  I'd love to get my hands on that original memo, because I'd gladly bet a Salmon P. Chase that it outlines a procedure that follows exactly MIGOP rule 19-C(2).  All the creative rewriting on the planet isn't going to save Mister National Popular Vote, or Michigan's Native Son, if that original memo happens to surface.

    In the meantime, I'm thinking that we ought to be making as much hay as possible out of this, as well as applying lots and lots of pressure to the MIGOP Credentials Committee to revisit last night's decision.  The phone numbers you'll need are these:

    • 517-487-5413 - Michigan Republican Party Main Office, through which you can reach Credentials Committee members Robert Schostak (rschostak@migop.org), Sharon Wise (swise@migop.org), and Holly Hughes (holly@hollyhughes.com)
    • 517-394-9940 - Saul Anuzis (sanuzis@gmail.com), Credentials Committee member (office phone number for Coast to Coast Strategies)
    • 517-371-8241 - Eric Doster (edoster@fosterswift.com), Credentials Committee member (phone number provided by the MIGOP directory)
    • 734-953-4092 - Mike Cox (cox1916@msn.com), Credentials Committee member (phone number provided by the MIGOP directory)
    • 313-565-3833 - Bill Runco (wjrunco@aol.com), Credentials Committee member (phone number provided by the MIGOP directory)

    Of course, anyone you happen to find listed in the 2011 Michigan Republican Party Directory (detailed contact info starts on page 10) who also happens to be on this list of Michigan Leaders Lining Up For Romney would also be a fine individual to contact as well.

    And, for what it's worth, an organization calling itself "Stop the MI GOP Corruption" has launched an online petition drive in an effort to shame the Credentials Committee into revisiting and reversing its decision.  (I find signature # 45 a tad interesting.)  I recommend sharing the link around.


    < Android Programming Upgrade Required | Game On, Mr. Schostak >


    Share This: Digg! StumbleUpon del.icio.us reddit reddit


    Display: Sort:
    Just disgusting (none / 0) (#1)
    by Corinthian Scales on Thu Mar 01, 2012 at 05:20:23 PM EST
    Chair Schostak has become the architect of demise as leader of the MI-GOP.  Saul's been a longtime useful idiot in the Party and probably still will be as long as his knee-pads pay the bills.

    Not much difference... the Democrats changed the rules to get what they wanted too.

    Rules (none / 0) (#2)
    by JGillman on Thu Mar 01, 2012 at 06:20:03 PM EST
    RULE 19 C (2) of the STATE RULES for the Michigan Republican Presidential Delegate Selection Process:

    C. Determining the Number of Delegates and Alternate Delegates to be Committed to Each Presidential Candidate

    Except as provided in Rule 19E, National Convention delegates and alternate delegates shall be elected based on the votes casts as uncommitted or for each respective Republican presidential candidate of the Republican Party's total statewide vote at the Presidential Preference Vote. The determination of these allocations shall be made as follows:

    (1) The Republican presidential candidate (or, if applicable, uncommitted) who receives the most votes in the Presidential Preference Vote for a
    congressional district shall be allocated the three (3) National Convention delegates and three (3) National Convention alternate delegates for that
    particular congressional district.

    (2) National Convention at-large delegates and at-large alternate delegates shall be elected on a basis that insures that the proportion of the at-largeNational Convention delegation that is committed to each Republican presidential candidate equals, as nearly as is practicable, the proportion of the statewide vote that was cast for each respective presidential candidate (or, if applicable, uncommitted) at the statewide Presidential Preference Vote. The determination of these proportions shall only include the votes cast for that particular Republican presidential candidate (or, if applicable, uncommitted), if the total vote cast for that particular Republican presidential candidate (or, if applicable, uncommitted), equals at least fifteen percent (15%) of the total statewide vote cast for all Republican presidential candidates (or, if applicable, uncommitted) at the Presidential Preference Vote (hereinafter the "Threshold Vote").

    The State Party Chair shall assure that the proportion of the at-large National Convention delegation committed to a particular presidential
    candidate (or, if applicable, uncommitted) is equal to the proportion of the statewide Presidential Preference Vote. That number shall be determined
    by dividing the total statewide Presidential Preference Vote received by each presidential candidate (or, if applicable, uncommitted) by the total
    statewide Presidential Preference Vote cast for all Republican presidential candidates (or, if applicable, uncommitted), not including within the total statewide Presidential Preference Vote those votes cast for any candidate (or, if applicable, uncommitted) that did not equal or exceed the Threshold Vote. The resulting percentage for each candidate (or, if applicable, uncommitted) shall be multiplied by fourteen (14) and rounded to the
    nearest whole number (.5 and above rounds up, below .5 rounds down), which shall be the number of delegates and alternate delegates that that
    candidate (or, if applicable, uncommitted) shall receive from the at-large National Convention delegation. If as a result of rounding off to the
    nearest whole number, there are more than fourteen (14) delegate and alternate positions assigned, the number of positions shall be decreased to
    fourteen (14) by subtracting the necessary number of positions from the Republican presidential candidate (or, if applicable, uncommitted)
    receiving the fewest votes cast at the Presidential Preference Vote. If as a result of rounding off to the nearest whole number, there are less than
    fourteen (14) delegate and alternate positions assigned, the number of positions shall be increased to fourteen (14) by adding the necessary
    number of positions to the Republican presidential candidate (or, if applicable, uncommitted) receiving the most votes cast at the Presidential
    Preference Vote.

    Beyond the Rules (none / 0) (#3)
    by JGillman on Thu Mar 01, 2012 at 07:55:06 PM EST
    In Schostak's own words
    From NBC's First Read:
       "We start off with, after the penalty, 30 voting delegates. Okay? Each district-congressional district - you can win individually. So you have 14 districts you can win two delegates. That takes you to 28. Okay? The two at-large that remain, provided the individual candidate won at least 15 percent of the statewide vote - okay so with four candidates that's likely to happen. Then they get awarded proportionally, those delegates, and then rounded to the nearest decimal point so there won't be any half delegates or quarter delegates."

    AUDIO HERE

    Bagdad Bob Schostak (none / 0) (#4)
    by Corinthian Scales on Thu Mar 01, 2012 at 09:04:42 PM EST
    Ya, that nickname should stick on him.

    Cox said that according to the MRP rules, Santorum and Romney should each get one of Michigan's two at-large delegates based on their take of the popular vote.

    "I supported Mitt, but the vote was clearly wrong," Cox said of the Credentials Committee.  "It's kind of like Third World voting.  We published rules and then we voted to change the rules."



    Verbatim? (none / 0) (#8)
    by Pogo on Fri Mar 02, 2012 at 08:17:48 AM EST
    Is Mr. Hoogendyk quoting the Feb. 7 memo here? http://coreprinciples.blogspot.com/2012/03/dele-gate-copy-of-rules.html

    Display: Sort:

    Login

    Make a new account

    Username:
    Password:
    Tweet along with RightMichigan by
    following us on Twitter HERE!
    create account | faq | search