Political News and Commentary with the Right Perspective. NAVIGATION
  • Front Page
  • News
  • Multimedia
  • Tags
  • RSS Feed


  • Advertise on RightMichigan.com


    NEWS TIPS!

    Get the RightMighigan.com toolbar!


    RightMichigan.com

    Buzz

    Who are the NERD fund donors Mr Snyder?

    Raise the curtain.

    Do you really want to fix Detroit's Public Schools?


    By KG One, Section News
    Posted on Mon Sep 05, 2011 at 08:30:23 PM EST
    Tags: DPS, ALL Public Schools, Why not go with something that works?, Parent Revolution, Parent Trigger Law (all tags)

    ~ Promoted For Discussion ~

    How about all under-performing/failing Michigan Public Schools?

    With Labor Day winding down and summer officially now over, we can start focusing on the things needed to get Michigan going again.

    Okay, okay, so our elected officials don't really start working until this Wednesday (must be nice), but now is a good as time as any to get the dialogue going here.

    So far, on Lansing's Agenda for this fall:

    -    Passing Freedom to Work legislation for Michigan.
    -    Getting another bridge built across the Detroit River.
    -    Making all of Michigan's Public Schools, Schools of Choice.

    That last one sounds great on paper.

    Not satisfied with how little Johnny's/Suzie's education is progressing?

    Just yank `em out of their under-performing school and put them into any district you want that has an available seat.

    Those other districts, you want the money. I know they do. So sit down, shut up and do as we in Lansing tell you to do.

    How does that really solve the underlying problem?

    {Continued after the fold}

    Provided that your child is not very academically hindered for their grade level, it may mean little to nothing to the other students in their new class. But what if they are not? What if they're not accustomed to rules and being held to acting in a certain manner? And worse yet, what if they're not alone?

    Multiply that number by 5, 10, or even 15 students per classroom who need additional work, and not only is that additional money Lansing is dangling like a dime bag to a crack addict quickly spent, but now you're infringing on the rights of the children living in that district who have to sit idly by while their teacher(s) now have to focus their attention away from those who want to learn and instead focus those energies on getting other students up to the proper level and maintaining order in the classroom.

    Where I come from, we call that dumping your problem in someone else's lap.

    Yeah, yeah, KG. We've heard this all before. Tell us something we haven't heard before.

    Okay then, here it comes.

    The gist of the debate from what I've seen so far can be categorizes as a.) The individual right of an education shouldn't be infringed by others who lack personal responsibility, and b.) Education is important, how we actually achieve that outcome be damned.

    So those who can escape failing schools will escape. And in the end, we're still stuck with children in non-achieving schools.

    But why do we need to wait for the schools to actually fail? Why can't Lansing take a more proactive step and simply empower the parents to fix where they're already at?

    There is a law that began in California backed by a group called Parent Revolution.

    Parent Revolution also has an interesting theory regarding how it views the problem with education:

    "Parent Revolution believes that our schools are failing because they aren't designed to succeed - they are designed for grown-up, not children.  We believe the only way to fix this and truly transform public education is to make every decision in public education based on what is good for children, not grown-ups.  To make each and every decision as if it would literally affect someone's own child.  The only way to make this happen is to give power to the only people who care only about children - parents."

    To address this problem, they have proposed the "Parent Trigger" law which addresses that very issue.

    It is a very simple law.

    If your child is attending an under-performing school, you as a parent have the right to circulate a petition among other parents sending their children to that school. If you are able to get signatures from 51% of parents (or future parents) attending that particular school, then you have several options:

    1) Charter conversion: If there is a nearby charter school that is outperforming your child's failing school, parents can bring in that charter school to transform the failing school. The school will then be run by that charter school, not the school district, but it will continue to serve all the same students that have always attended the school.

    2) Turnaround: If parents want huge changes but want to leave the school district in charge, this option may be for them. It forces the school district to hit the reset button by bringing in a new staff and giving the local school community more control over staffing and budget.

    3) Transformation:  This is the least significant change. It forces the school district to find a new principal, and make a few other small changes.

    4) Closure: This option would close the school altogether and send the students to other, higher-performing schools nearby.  Parent Revolution does NOT recommend this option to parents - we believe schools must be transformed, not closed.

    5) Bargaining power: If parents want smaller changes but the school district just won't listen to them, they can organize, get to 51%, and use their signatures as bargaining power.

    An explanation of these can be seen here:

    This law isn't just limited to only California. It's beginning to take off all across America in states like Colorado, Ohio, New York, Mississippi, Connecticut, and Illinois (promoted by Rahm Emanuel...yes, Pres. Obama's former Chief of Staff).

    Much like Freedom to Work is causing the unions in general headaches, "Parent Trigger" laws are causing teachers union that and more. So much so, that school districts and their union supporters are doing their best to impede it.

    Case in point, the Compton School District back in April was "unable" to read 275 signatures on a petition submitted by parents.

    Another occurred in Connecticut during a teachers TEACH 2011 Conference, the Connecticut Teacher's Union got caught recently with their hand in the cookie jar when a powerpoint was found on their own website indicating how they coordinated sabotaging the efforts to help students by limiting the power of parents (think:RMGN here in Michigan).

    I can cite most sources, but it should be readily apparent that this law is scarring the hell out of the educational establishment. So the all important question to be asked now is what will it be?

    Will Lansing focus on dumping problems onto others like progressives are prone to do?

    Or will it empowering parents and eventually let the free market step in and solve the problem?

    < HAPPY LABOR DAY - HOFFA STYLE | A Good .. man? >


    Share This: Digg! StumbleUpon del.icio.us reddit reddit


    Display: Sort:
    All for free market (none / 0) (#1)
    by JGillman on Mon Sep 05, 2011 at 10:03:49 PM EST
    always.

    I should note, I am not one who believes education is a "right".  However, the method in which education dollars are taken from us all leaves no way to discern who is, or who is not, paying taxes somewhere along the way that support schools.  As long as we cannot determine the absolute money trail of EVERY dollar used to finance, it is wrong to not allow those who truly want to learn, another opportunity if it is available.  Especially if it is theoretically carried and funded by their own tax dollars.

    And YES I get how its likely poor Detroit parents don't pay as much as their neighbors but given the design of the system to date, it cannot matter.

    As for parents trigger laws. I like it.

    Thanks KG (none / 0) (#3)
    by archiespeck on Tue Sep 06, 2011 at 11:33:04 AM EST
    Thanks for a well articulated description of Parent Trigger. I have to admit I had not heard of this, but it addresses a lot of problems that schools of choice does not, namely in making sure PARENTS are the ones who are in control and chiefly responsible for making sure their child gets the best education possible.

    I can't imagine the conniption the MEA would throw were this introduced in Michigan.

    Display: Sort:

    Login

    Make a new account

    Username:
    Password:
    Tweet along with RightMichigan by
    following us on Twitter HERE!
    create account | faq | search