Political News and Commentary with the Right Perspective. NAVIGATION
  • Front Page
  • News
  • Multimedia
  • Tags
  • RSS Feed


  • Advertise on RightMichigan.com


    NEWS TIPS!

    Get the RightMighigan.com toolbar!


    RightMichigan.com

    Buzz

    Who are the NERD fund donors Mr Snyder?

    Raise the curtain.

    Republicans and Democrats: A contrast in leadership styles


    By Nick, Section News
    Posted on Thu Jan 31, 2008 at 07:12:11 AM EST
    Tags: (all tags)

    Every now and again you get one of those days with news at all levels of government in the State that actually paint a pretty good picture of the difference between Michigan Republicans and Democrats.  Today is one of those days.  Whether it's continued evaluation and reaction to the Governor's painful State of the State speech (clap... please?  PLEASE?!), a glimpse at actual legitimate leadership from the GOP or the festering text message scandal down in Detroit there's plenty to talk about and a pretty stark dichotomy.  

    So let's start at the top as observers, analysts and political and economic experts get a chance to really dig deep into what the Governor had to say this past Tuesday night.  One refrain that you saw echoed again and again in the press yesterday morning was that many Republicans thought the Governor sounded just like them.  Frankly, if she did, I wouldn't go around admitting that or trying to draw attention to that particular fact but that's just me.  

    They were right, however, that there were portions of her speech that seemed to point towards economic facts conservatives have been screaming from the mountain tops for the last five years.  Particularly, tax cuts, breaks and incentives work.  Fewer taxes means more jobs.  It's that economic reality that made last year's $2.4 billion Democrat tax hike all that much more miserable.  It's not just that they were taking that much cash out of the private sector but also the fact that they were running in the opposite direction of the kind of pro-growth policies the State really needs in order to rebound.

    Read on...

    So the Governor took to the rostrum and started talking, that massive, record breaking tax hike already securely in her back pocket, and what she had to say sounded a little bit surprising.  She had two plans to spur job growth, both of which relied exclusively on giving job makers monetary incentives (i.e. lower taxes) in order to invest and grow.  According to the FREEP:

    Invest Michigan! would divert up to $300 million in state pension funds to Michigan businesses that agree to hire more people. The state would recruit other investors for those companies.

    The second plan would give $35 million in state tax breaks to businesses in the top 50 growing sectors, based on national reports. Likely to be targeted are industries such as alternative energy, science research and data processing -- businesses that could easily locate elsewhere...

    Eligible new businesses would pay no business taxes for one year. Existing businesses that qualify would receive large tax credits.

    Those proposals, directly from the Governor's mouth, are an explicit admission that tax breaks work.  Fewer taxes, more jobs.  Period.  We've been saying that here since the launch of the site just about a year ago but economists have been saying that since the inception of taxes, jobs and the free market.  It's not a new reality but it is clearly a reality that Michigan Democrats have done their best to ignore and deny.

    It's no wonder many Republicans looked at that portion of the speech and thought the Governor sounded like one of them.  The principle is sound but the problem pops up in the application.

    If tax breaks and incentives work and stimulate job growth and job growth leads to increased tax revenues then why raise taxes in the first place and why not grant across the board cuts so that every Michigan business has a chance to grow.  The Governor's proposal is a real nice sounding band-aid solution.  It might stem the bleeding in one area or another but Michigan's economy is shot full of holes.  We need to address the underlying problems and fix the jobs environment, not simply slap a patch here and there.  That sort of thing rarely works, something that continues to fly over the heads of most libs but wasn't lost on the Michigan Chamber.  Freep continues:

    Democrats praised her ideas as catalysts for job growth, but Republicans and some business advocates questioned government's ability to mold the economy.

    "Any time you put government in direct competition with venture capitalists in the private sector, we would be concerned," said James Holcomb, vice president of business advocacy for the Michigan Chamber of Commerce. "Government doesn't have too good a record of picking winners and losers."

    So no, ladies and gentlemen, the Governor did not sound like a conservative on Tuesday night.  She sounded like a woman completely out of touch with economic reality.  But what else is new, right?  Until Michigan either A) gets new leadership or B) bottoms out we'll just have to take solace in the fact that at least now the Democrats are praising conservative principles as "catalysts for job growth" even if they don't understand how and why they work.  

    There's a problem that everyone recognizes and understands.  There's a solution that Republicans and Democrats all recognize and understand.  But while the GOP wants to act and to get something done the Democrats continue to stare those economic realities in the face, admit they're real, and then ignore the solution.  

    Contrast that with a bit of Republican leadership in Lansing, particularly on this whole drivers-licesnes-for-illegal-aliens issue.  The Associated Press reports:

    Cox was asked to rule on whether illegal immigrants should be able to get driver's licenses. Until last week, Michigan was one of the few states where illegals could legally get behind the wheel.

    Cox's opinion ended that practice, saying Michigan law prohibits the secretary of state from issuing a driver's license to a nonresident. The opinion said the Legislature stated a clear intent that a resident for purposes of Michigan's vehicle code must be permanent and not temporary or transient.

    His decision reversed an early opinion by former Democratic Attorney General Frank Kelley made in 1995. Attorney general opinions are legally binding on state agencies and officers unless reversed by the courts or state law is changed.

    Both Land and Cox are Republicans. Land interpreted the Cox opinion to mean immigrants who are here legally -- but aren't permanent residents -- can't get licenses. She has proposed legislation that would change that, allowing legal immigrants who are temporarily in the state to get licenses.

    There was a problem... illegal aliens were getting drivers licenses, making their attempts to stay in Michigan illegally infinitely easier.  There was a solution.  Stop giving them licenses.  Mike Cox and Terril Land did what they needed to do and solved the problem.  Now comes a new problem.  Legal aliens can't get licenses but should be able to.  So what's a lawmaker to do?

    If we were to follow the Jennifer Granholm leadership model we'd give a speech, talk about how important it is to give legal aliens the ability to drive legally and then we'd propose a solution that lets some legal aliens drive legally but not all legal aliens.  Only the ones that we really liked today and thought could help us earn votes tomorrow.  

    The GOP leadership model?  The Senate Republicans will be moving a fix as early as today that addresses the problem at it's root and applies a genuine, across the board solution.  Tackling a problem.  Novel concept in Lansing.  

    Novel concept in Detroit too, where, apparently, you can fire police officers to protect a secret affair, lie about that secret affair under oath, settle a lawsuit by charging millions of dollars to the city's credit card to silence those police officers years after the fact and then when you get caught you can just say "I'm sorry" and pretend like nothing even happened.  Time to `get back to work' for the American people... err... the people of the city of Detroit.  Sorry, mixed up my Democrat leaders receiving sexual favors from subordinates on taxpayer time and then lying about it under oath.  Honest mistake.  

    Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick gave his big "my bad" speech last night and coverage is sort of being done to death but there was one frustrating bit in this morning's Detroit News op-ed.  One frustrating bit other than the fact they're ready to give Hizzoner a pass for committing perjury.  

    It was painful to hear the mayor explain his turmoil when discussing the scandal with his wife and children. Any parent can relate. And it wasn't hard to imagine wife and children's pain, especially when Carlita Kilpatrick spoke from the heart during the broadcast.

    Any parent can relate?  Maybe I'm just one of those crazy old fashioned guys but I've got to believe there are still parents out there who have never cheated on their spouse.  Who are loving and faithful and entirely unwilling to sacrifice the best things in their life for a moment or two of passing pleasure.  There are parents all across the State of Michigan who have no idea what it would be like to have to have the sort of conversation the News is talking about here and do not, by the grace of God and their own self control, have any frame of reference by which they can relate.  

    Heaven help us if I'm wrong. But hey, at the very least this gives us one more example of Democrat "leadership."

    < Michigan: The Most Pro-Life State in the Union! | Thursday in the Sphere, January 31 >


    Share This: Digg! StumbleUpon del.icio.us reddit reddit


    Display: Sort:
    Granholm Economy (none / 0) (#1)
    by Rougman on Thu Jan 31, 2008 at 09:54:10 AM EST
    Now Nick, don't tell me you are against a state controlled central economy.  It has worked so well in all the other socialist states in the world, why not give it a shot here? </sarcasm>

    Strange thing with Michigan (none / 0) (#2)
    by LX on Thu Jan 31, 2008 at 12:55:06 PM EST
    None of my friends, myself included, can ever find anyone willing to say that they voted for Jenny MoleRattler.

    As far as the whole Cox issue with him finally getting off his @ss making a ruling that went against him pandering to all the illegals and their anchor families in Wayne County 5 years later. Big whoop. Must have been like having a root cannel for him with forcing himself to say, "Look, you are illegal aliens sneaking into America, you are already lawbreakers and you do not have the constitutional rights and privileges of natural born and naturalized citizens. Now please have your legal family members vote for me if I run for governor in 2010." Way to go Mike, that was really difficult and just as with King Kwame, he too has admitted to playing outside his marriage. I hope that I am not sensing with this topic that the mere fact that Cox has an R next to his name makes him any better of a person, because he clearly isn't.

    Now, this issue of providing a driver's license to legal aliens is a serious matter. They too fall through the cracks as with many of them that have visas that expire and they stay just here.

    Allow this little story from 12/07/07 illustrate how just one individual cost all of us taxpayers in Michigan $605,000.00 all because this one Romanian, Dumitru Nistorescu, slipped through the crack's on a visa that expired in 2005.

    http://www.freep.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20071207/BUSINESS06/712070388

    Also, note that Dearborn is referenced in the article, and remember Cox purposely botched popping a whole heard of middle easterners committing Medicaid fraud associated with ACCESS.

    Anyway, back to the real point, to simply hand out a driver's license, an identification card that opens up a completely new world for even a legal alien is completely irresponsible for the state to do. A more secure suggestion for the state is to issue a permit that expires every 90 days that is not valid for identification purposes, which must be used in conjunction with the photo ID on their (legal aliens) countries passport or visas.

    One more thing, thank you and God bless you Nick, for calling them illegal aliens and not this insipid illegal immigrant brain drain term. Finally, the proper language is used in describing what they are.


    Certainly legislative Repubs sound like Governess (none / 0) (#5)
    by Angry White Male on Thu Jan 31, 2008 at 10:05:32 PM EST
    She wants to borrow and spend, they want to borrow and spend.

    She wants to impose nonsense "renewable" electricity mandates, they want to also.

    She wants to lock up our groundwater resources from commercial and industrial users, so do they.

    She wants to put politics before good public policy, that's their middle name.

    The legislative Republicans are not your friends. There are not more than two or three that have even a thimble-full of principle. RM is waaaaay too lenient - give those SOBs the hell they deserve!



    Display: Sort:

    Login

    Make a new account

    Username:
    Password:
    Tweet along with RightMichigan by
    following us on Twitter HERE!
    create account | faq | search