Political News and Commentary with the Right Perspective. NAVIGATION
  • Front Page
  • News
  • Multimedia
  • Tags
  • RSS Feed


  • Advertise on RightMichigan.com


    NEWS TIPS!

    Get the RightMighigan.com toolbar!


    RightMichigan.com

    Buzz

    Who are the NERD fund donors Mr Snyder?

    Raise the curtain.

    Michigan Voters Overwhelmingly Oppose Speaker Dillon's Mandatory State Government-Run Health Plan


    By MonFineis, Section News
    Posted on Tue Dec 15, 2009 at 11:55:02 AM EST
    Tags: Andy Dillon, health plan, government health plan, Michigan taxpayers (all tags)

    Two Statewide Polls by Different Firms Find Strong Opposition

    With two surveys of Michigan voters now finding strong opposition to House Speaker Andy Dillon's proposed  mandatory state government-run health insurance plan, it's little wonder hearings on legislation to implement the plan have been halted and key witnesses have not been allowed to testify.

    On Monday, EPIC*MRA released a new survey of Michigan voters that found strong opposition to House Bill 5345 among Democratic, Republican and Independent voters. In September, a survey of Michigan voters conducted by Lansing-based Marketing Resource Group (MRG) also found wide opposition to the scheme to force all public employers in Michigan and nearly 1.5 million residents to give up their private health insurance and instead get their insurance from a state government plan that would be created by the Legislature and run by 13 political appointees of the governor and Legislature.

    In both surveys, voters expressed concerns with the mandatory nature of the legislation, the risks and costs to Michigan taxpayers, and state government's ability to manage the plan.

    "House Bill 5345 is viewed as bad and risky public policy by Michigan voters, and legislators who support it will find it to be toxic in 2010 and beyond," said Roger Martin, spokesman for Citizens for Accountability in Reform, a growing coalition representing taxpayers, police, firefighters, teachers, insurance companies and others who are concerned House Bill 5345 doesn't provide the reform it promises at a price taxpayers can afford.

    Martin noted that a House committee holding hearings on the bill has announced that today's scheduled hearing will be the last for possibly months, even though 10 more bills were introduced late last week to implement the $4 billion to $5 billion state government health plan.

    "With an election year just around the corner, given Michigan voters' overwhelming opposition to this legislation, it's no wonder the committee doesn't want to hold more hearings," Martin said.

    "During the hearings over the past two months, so many witnesses have either voiced opposition or raised serious concerns, opposition to the legislation among voters has skyrocketed."

    The vast majority of witnesses at the House hearings have expressed concerns or outright opposition to the legislation, including representatives of local governments, executives of health plans, representatives of labor unions and school districts, the head of the House Fiscal Agency, independent actuaries, and more. Witnesses have said the claimed savings are grossly over-estimated, the risks and costs to taxpayers are under-estimated, and constitutional problems with the bill are not even being acknowledged.

    "A number of people with additional concerns wanted to testify and have been told they would not be allowed," Martin said.

    "We know, for example, that witnesses have asked to present their concerns about reproductive rights and domestic partner benefits. We know Public Policy Associates, which has completed the only thorough analysis of the legislation, has asked to testify, but has basically been told 'no.' We are going to make sure their concerns are heard by the people, by legislators, and the news media, even if the committee has stopped the public hearings."

    Here are quick summaries of the EPIC*MRA and MRG polls (more information can be found at www.accountabilityinreform.com):

    *    The EPIC*MRA survey of 600 voters, completed Dec. 9, found only 22 percent of Michigan voters support the legislation. A 59 percent majority opposed the legislation when first asked, and after hearing arguments both in favor of and against the proposal, opposition grew to 71 percent. A 78 to 16 percent majority said local governments, universities, colleges, local schools and their employees should not be forced to join a state government plan and the decision should be voluntary.

    *    In the MRG survey of 600 voters, conducted Sept. 12-20, opposition was strong at 57 percent to 37 percent. The MRG poll found especially strong opposition among behavioral Republicans: 72 percent of GOP voters opposed the bill.

    In both surveys, Michigan voters were alarmed by the costs to state government and taxpayers of setting up and running the plan for the first year, estimated at about $870 million. Opposition also increased after voters learned taxpayer bailouts have occurred in other states with mandatory and voluntary public employer health insurance plans. This year in North Carolina - one of the few states with a mandatory health insurance plan for public employers - the Legislature turned to taxpayers to bail out the plan's deficit to the tune of more than $250 million this year and $658 million over two years.

    "Michigan voters believe it's a bad idea and risky for taxpayers to force all local governments and their employees onto a state government-run plan that voters believe is going to cost more to set up and run than it will ever save," Martin said.

    "They just don't believe state government can provide health insurance to 1.5 million people at a lower cost than the private sector and their local governments, schools, colleges and universities. It's also fact that not a single expert who has testified at any of the hearings has offered one shred of evidence to prove that the voters are wrong."

    < Cherry calls for more Job Losses | In the MACKINAC CENTER Sphere Today >


    Share This: Digg! StumbleUpon del.icio.us reddit reddit


    Display: Sort:
    Other surveys (none / 0) (#3)
    by Rougman on Thu Dec 17, 2009 at 11:18:33 AM EST
    On the bright side, extensive surveys of people in other countries who are already dead because of their crappy national health care systems, seem to show no preference one way or the other.

    There were no complaints whatsoever.  

    Display: Sort:

    Login

    Make a new account

    Username:
    Password:
    Tweet along with RightMichigan by
    following us on Twitter HERE!

    Related Links

    + Also by MonFineis
    create account | faq | search